So you’ve left your job…now what?
Change is the Only Constant
Changing jobs is a big deal. Whether it was planned or more sudden, change brings about a mixture of complex emotions and questions. One of those questions that I get all the time in my career as a financial advisor is “What happens to my 401(k)?” From fears of losing money to just uncertainty about what comes next, I have worked with clients all along the spectrum.
Your Money is Your Money
The first thing to understand about your 401(k) is that the money that you put into the plan is your money. Any salary deferrals into the plan belong to you on day one, regardless of any vesting schedule. Even if you decide to change jobs every six months, any money you contributed to your retirement plan that would have otherwise been on your paycheck is yours to keep. The same is true for any investment gains (or losses!) that those contributions incurred.
Factoring that in when you consider the importance of contributing regularly to your 401(k) (covered by my colleague Dr. Anessa earlier), it should be clear that there shouldn’t be anything holding you back from putting whatever extra income you can into your retirement plan.
That said, it is a bit less straightforward when it comes to money contributed by your employer.
Their Money Might be Your Money, Too
When you join an employer and sign up for their 401(k) plan, they will usually talk about “matching” contributions. Employer matching is one of the biggest benefits of a retirement plan out there.
The exact schedule of matching will be determined by your employer and laid out in their Summary Plan Description (SPD) document. A common approach is to match dollar-for-dollar the first 3 percent of your contributions and then half of the next 2 percent of your contributions. Under this schedule of matching if you contribute 5 percent or more of your income to your 401(k), your employer will contribute the equivalent of an additional 4 percent of your income. But here’s the catch: that additional 4 percent is typically not your money, at least not on day 1.
See, employers want you to stick around for a few years, and one way to incentivize that is to impose a “vesting schedule.” Vesting is just a fancy way of saying how much you actually own of the employer contributions. (Remember, contributions from money that was already going to you as income are 100 percent yours right away.) For example, if you are 40 percent vested on $10,000 of employer contributions, then if you leave your job you only keep $4,000 and forfeit the remainder.
Plans can differ on how quickly they vest, so before you make any rash decisions to quit your job, it is worthwhile to double check your vesting schedule to see how much, if any, you are forfeiting by leaving!
Now that you have double-checked your vesting, realized you are 100 percent vested in your employer contributions (or can afford to forfeit the un-vested amount), and have decided it is time to move onto bigger and better pastures, you are probably wondering what your options are. Let’s break them down:
- Leave it where it is
- Roll it into your new employer’s plan
- Roll it into an IRA
- Cash it out
Option 1: Leave it Be
Typically, the simplest approach is to leave the money in your old employer’s plan. This is usually an available option, although that is not always the case, particularly if you have a very small balance. For example, I have read plan documents that mandate that you move the account out within a certain period of time if your balance was less than $1,000. Otherwise, you usually reserve the right to just let the money sit there.
Let’s face it, when you are in the middle of changing jobs there is usually quite a bit of stress on you at that time already. Acclimating to a new role, new coworkers, and new management can be enough to deal with without having to add on the paperwork and chore of moving funds from one custodian to another. That said, whether or not it is a good idea to leave your money where it is depends greatly on the plan’s available investment options, the fees associated with the plan, and your capacity and desire to manage additional accounts and custodians.
Options 2 & 3: Roll it into Something New
Once you are up and firing at your new job, enrolled in their retirement plan, and settled into things, then you may want to consolidate accounts. After all, most people would agree that it is easier to manage things at one financial institution compared to having two (or more!) to deal with.
Prior to making any moves though, I would strongly recommend reviewing the fees at the new custodian as well as double-checking that the plan can accept roll-ins in the first place. Most plans can, particularly if it is a 401(k), but if your new plan is a different type of retirement plan (like a TSP, 457, or deferred compensation, just to name a few) it may be a bit less straightforward. The first phone call you make should be to your new plan to confirm they will accept the money and see what paperwork they need you to complete.
Another option you have after leaving an employer is to roll their employer retirement money into an IRA. This option is particularly attractive to new retirees who will not have access to a new employer plan because they are not working anymore! IRAs typically offer low fees, more investment options, and easier access to distributions than a 401(k) plan does, so they can be quite attractive to consider.
While an IRA has a lot going for it, there are also definitely some reasons you might not want to roll money into an IRA, particularly if you are retiring between age 55 and 59.5. If you leave your job in that age range and think there is any chance you may need access to your retirement savings before turning 59.5, you should strongly consider leaving your money inside of the plan to preserve the “Rule of 55.” This exception allows you to access your retirement accounts without the extra 10 percent penalty for early distributions, and is only available inside of the employer plan from the company you retired from age 55 or later.
Option 4: Cash Out
This is generally going to be the last option to consider. While you do reserve the right to cash out your 401(k) money, you could wind up being hit with a large and unexpected tax bill as well as penalties on top of that depending on your age. If you are considering cashing out your retirement plan, you absolutely need to consult a retirement and tax advisor before doing so.
As you can see, there is quite a large decision tree to work through prior to deciding on what to do with your retirement plan after leaving your employer. Whether you are still working, your age, and your goals are all important factors to consider prior to implementing anything. Consult a fiduciary, someone who will “tell it to you straight” what the best option is for you personally, and don’t be afraid to ask for help.
Jacob Yocco, CFP®