Medicare – Changes Over the Years

Looking back at some of the changes that I have seen to Medicare and their impacts on you.

Changing of the Seasons

It’s the most wonderful time of the year! Time to sit down with family, enjoy some holiday cheer, and look back at some of the growth & change you have experienced together. Wait… but it is only October? Okay, maybe it is a bit early for Christmas (try telling that to my wife who listens to Christmas music in July though!) but time does fly, and somehow we are sitting here in October again already. If I know anything about October, it is that it brings its own special season: Medicare Annual Enrollment.

It may not be quite as cheerful as baking cookies with your family and opening up a present from a dear loved one, but it has to be a close second right? All jokes aside, it is indeed the Medicare Annual Enrollment period again, and I thought: there is no better time to sit down and look back at some of the changes that I have seen to the program over the past several years.

Medicare Supplements

I started my career in sales of Medicare Supplement policies, Advantage Plans, and Part D prescription drug plans back in 2016, and what I have learned over my time in the industry is that “the only constant is change.”

The first big change I can remember seeing is the phasing out of Plan F. When I first started, Plan F was one of the two most popular supplement plans that we sold, but odds are if you are reading this blog today, you do not have a Plan F. The reason is that in 2015 the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act (MACRA) made Plan F unavailable to people joining Medicare January 1, 2020, or later. While, technically, Plan F is still available today to people who were “grandfathered in” by being on Medicare before 2020, it is pretty rare that I see someone who actually has the plan now in 2025.

Today, the most commonly purchased plan is Plan G, which is very similar to Plan F. The difference is that under Plan G you have some “skin in the game” in the form of the Part B deductible. Plan F paid all of your out-of-pocket expenses for products and services covered by Medicare including the Part B deductible, but with Plan G you have to pay that deductible yourself. The deductible has gone up over time, but in 2025 it is still only $257 compared to $166 in 2016.

Part D

Probably my favorite changes to Medicare have come very recently with the Inflation Reduction Act’s impact on Part D prescription drug plans (aka PDPs). I remember helping clients out reviewing drug plans back around 2017-2018, and when I would start to hear they had insulins, inhalers, or other specialty drugs I would start to fear what I was going to see for expected drug costs for the year. I would occasionally see expected total costs as high as $20,000 for the year just for medications. Yes, you read that right; twenty thousand dollars for medications for just one year.

On top of the expected costs, the PDPs were incredibly difficult for clients to understand. There were different co-pays depending on the phase of coverage. Have you met your deductible? Great, now you have reached the Initial Coverage Level and have a new co-pay. After a while, you may hit the infamous “Donut Hole” where your costs would spike up drastically. Finally, after you had paid thousands of dollars towards medications, you could reach Catastrophic Coverage where your co-pays would drop and level out again. Confused yet? I would be shocked if you were not!

Coming into 2025, there were major changes to the Part D system that kicked in. These changes capped out-of-pocket expenses at $2,000 for the calendar year and officially closed the donut hole that had caused so many Medicare beneficiaries financial strain. There are also now caps on costs of certain medications – maybe the most famous of which is the cap on the cost of insulins at a $35 co-pay, as long as the particular insulin is on the plan’s formulary of covered drugs.

Starting next year, more drugs like Eliquis (a common blood thinner) are set to have lower costs as well due to the Medicare Drug Price Negotiation Program. What exactly this will look like for your co-pays at the pharmacy remains to be seen at the time of writing this blog, but hopefully we will see these negotiated costs trickle down to monthly savings.

Medicare Advantage

Another change I have noticed over my years working with Medicare beneficiaries is that there has been a growing trend towards choosing Medicare Advantage. When I sold both types of plans, I typically recommended Original Medicare with a Medicare Supplement instead of Medicare Advantage, but the statistics from health policy research organization KFF show that the percentage of enrollees electing to go with Medicare Advantage have grown substantially since 2016. The share of Medicare-eligible persons enrolling in Medicare Advantage was 51 percent in 2023 compared to 33 percent in 2016. KFF also projects that it will continue to grow over the next several years because of the extra benefits and the marketing of “zero premium.”

Bumping Up for Inflation

Annually, there is also change that occurs in the form of Income Related Monthly Adjustment Amounts (IRMAA). For those who have never had the displeasure of receiving an IRMAA notice, it is an increase in your monthly Medicare Part B & Part D premiums because of high income. Because the income data comes from tax filings, IRMAA has a lagging effect to it as well. So rather than using your income in the current year, Medicare is looking at your income numbers from two years ago. Every year, Medicare adjusts the threshold for inflation.

For comparison, during my first year working on Medicare sales in 2016, the cutoff for the first tier of IRMAA for a married couple filing jointly was $170,000 in income. Fast forward to 2025 and the cutoff for the first tier is now $212,000. If your income is just $1 over the cutoff, then you pay a 40 percent higher Part B premium. It is important to keep a close eye on IRMAA thresholds when doing your tax planning for the year with your financial advisor.

As a CFP® professional and financial advisor, my role has changed significantly since I first started my career. Originally, I worked in Medicare plan sales pretty much all day, every day; however, now it is much more on the periphery of my day-to-day work. That said, I am passionate about ensuring that my clients have insurance that will serve them well and protect them in their retirement, so I am happy to put my background in Medicare to work to help clients review their insurance each year.

While the Medicare system has changed a fair bit over the past 10 years, I am confident that my experience in the industry as well as keeping up with the changes that occur annually put me in a position to take good care of our clients. If you have any questions about your insurance this fall, please reach out to our team here at Cardinal. We will be happy to help.

Jacob Yocco, CFP®

Have questions? Contact us today.