Building a financial plan with one of the hardest things to find in the world – Guarantees
Building From the Bottom Up
When it comes to financial planning, just about everyone faces the same challenge: How do I build a plan that is not just strong today but remains stable over decades? It is true that financial planning is not something that is figured out once and then is done; a financial plan is something that should change and develop over time as your needs and goals change. But at the core of things there needs to be a strong foundation on which things are built, or else you can risk it all falling apart.
When you set out to build a house, you do not just grab a few pieces of lumber, some nails, and a hammer and get to work! No; you create a blueprint and a variety of tools to build things from the ground up. Just like building a home, advisors need to ensure that there is a strong base at the bottom of your financial plan and build up from there with the right tools. But how do we build that foundation in a world where the market fluctuates all the time, interest rates rise and drop, and general economic uncertainty runs rampant? We look for something that is guaranteed and predictable (and no, I am not talking about the 3 guarantees Buddy discussed a few weeks ago!).
A New Tool in the Toolbox
One useful plan-building material that provides this sort of guarantee is a Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA). Think of a MYGA as the concrete in the foundation of your house. Having just moved to a new development neighborhood in Winston Salem, I have seen tons of home footings lining the blocks these past few months. And just as these foundations are serving as the base for the homes Lennar are throwing up left and right, a MYGA can serve as a strong base to help support the rest of your financial structure.
A MYGA is a type of fixed annuity issued by insurance companies. In exchange for locking up a lump sum of money for a certain number of years, the insurance company guarantees you a fixed interest rate for those years. It even provides that growth tax-deferred, so for funds in taxable non-retirement accounts you also benefit from delaying taxes on the gains until the end of the contract.
Guaranteed growth is something that is hard to find. If you invest in fixed income mutual funds or exchange traded funds (ETFs), then you will find that you are exposing yourself to bond duration risk, and the price can fluctuate greatly based on changes in interest rates. I have been using treasury bills and notes for clients a lot over the past few years because they have bond covenants, which, unlike bond funds, do guarantee you will receive your principal back at the end of the term. However, the US Treasury is not considered quite as risk free as it has been in years past. We still believe the US Treasury is just about the safest lender out there, but we are more cautious about it than we were a few years ago.
Rather than dumping too much cash into any one lender (yes, even the US Treasury!), I look for alternative options that can also provide a guarantee to help build an investment foundation. MYGAs are an avenue to receive a guarantee that is backed by a different counter-party than the US Treasury and sometimes even offer higher rates.
Different Strokes for Different Folks
While I have been talking about MYGAs being a secure base for your plan, it is important to realize that not all foundations are created equal or for the same purpose. There are tons of different insurance companies out there offering MYGA products that differ in interest rates, liquidity features, income riders, and more. So how do you evaluate the right features for your plan?
The first place I always like to look at is the financial stability of the company and the interest rate they are offering. Credit rating agencies like AM Best offer assessments on financial strength and ability to pay claims for each insurance company, and typically you will find that the lower-rated companies are offering a slightly higher interest rate to attract business. This “risk premium” may be attractive to some investors looking for a higher return on their investment for more risk, but I would argue that in the case of looking for something to build your investment plan on, you will want to stick to something A-rated or better – even if it means sacrificing a bit of interest to do so.
The next feature I look for is access to liquidity in the contract. I mentioned earlier that you are locking up the lump sum for the duration of the contract, but that is not entirely true. Many companies offer access to 10 percent of your account value per year of the contract, or they will allow withdrawals for Required Minimum Distributions from IRA contracts. Even if you are not expecting to need access to the funds for the entire duration of the contract, having this liquidity feature provides some flexibility.
For example, you might find that 2 years into a 5-year contract, interest rates have risen. It can make sense then to utilize that 10 percent free withdrawal rider in a contract to take that money and reinvest it – maybe into bonds or even into a new MYGA at a higher rate. In the case of financial planning, building a strong foundation includes building in flexibility to go back and improve upon it later!
The Exit Strategy
Another part of the flexibility of a MYGA comes at the end of the contract. I mentioned earlier that taxable accounts can benefit from tax-deferred growth until the end of the contract. Well, let’s say that you are not quite ready to foot that tax bill when the time comes for the contract to end. In that case, you can utilize a 1035 Exchange, effectively just moving the money into a new annuity contract and continuing the tax-deferred growth. For qualified IRA contracts, you can move the funds back to an IRA at your investment custodian (like Charles Schwab) and reinvest the funds there without the tax implications of a distribution.
If you do not feel the need to delay the tax hit or are ready to use the money for another purpose, you can just bite the tax bullet and cash it out as scheduled. It is important to build from the ground up in any financial plan, but unlike with houses, financial foundations are not permanent, and so it is also important to have an exit strategy that you can employ when the time is right.
It is also important to acknowledge that the foundation is not the whole house. Just like it is important that a home include a frame, walls, and a roof, you need to build beyond the guarantees of your plan as well. Equity funds and stocks can serve as the framework to build upwards, and the cash on hand in savings and money market accounts can be your walls and roof to protect against rainy days. When you add it all together, you wind up with a house that you can afford to relax in and decorate creatively because you know that it is solidly built.
At this point, you should have a better understanding of multi-year guaranteed annuities and why I feel they can serve a good role in an overall financial plan. They are not the solution to all financial planning needs, but they are a great tool to have in the toolbox when we work together to build the foundation for your financial plan.
Jacob Yocco, CFP®