Ways to reduce risk without selling
Concentrated Stock Damages Diversification
One of the best parts of my job is seeing things go right. Whether it’s a financial planning strategy delivering real tax savings, or a client reaching a retirement milestone they had worked decades toward, the joy in this work can be crystal clear and straightforward.
There are situations, though, where there is too much of a good thing – where the clear joy of a winning investment becomes entangled with taxes, risk, and a harder conversation than the win itself would suggest. What I’m talking about is clients with concentrated stock positions: a single holding that has grown to represent an outsized share of their net worth, often well above the 5 percent threshold that most of us would consider a comfortable allocation for a single stock.
This situation is more common among successful households than most people realize. It shows up for founders and early employees who took equity instead of cash, for executives who accumulated stock through years of grants, for professionals who bought into a conviction stock decades ago and never had a reason to sell, and for families who inherited a position their parents never wanted to touch.
Regardless of the origins, the pattern is the same: a single holding has grown large enough that the household’s financial future is now quietly tied to the fate of one company, and the very thing that created the wealth — patience, conviction, tax deferral — is what makes it hard to unwind.
Why “Just Sell It” Is Incomplete Advice
Selling a concentrated stock position solves the risk problem, but it creates a tax problem in its place. The size and nature of the affect depends on the size of the gain, the household’s other income, the state of residence, and other factors.
For example, a single large sale can trigger the Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT, a 3.8 percent surtax above $200,000/$250,000 in MAGI), inflate premiums for Medicare beneficiaries two years down the road, push a household into a higher capital gains bracket, or (in states that tax capital gains as ordinary income, including California and New York) come with no preferential rate at all. For many of our clients, the honest answer to “should I sell” is that selling is not the default first move. The real work is figuring out how much of the position needs to change, how quickly, and through which combination of tools.
This is where we think a good advisor earns their fee: not by picking the next stock, but by building a plan that treats the concentrated position as one piece of a household’s entire balance sheet and tax return, rather than an isolated trading decision.
Strategies to Manage Concentrated Stock Risk
Rather than treating a concentrated position as something to be eliminated as fast as possible, we usually start with a different question: what would this household’s portfolio look like if the position were sized appropriately, and how do we get there with the least cost along the way? Here are four tools we consider most often:
1) Custom Direct Indexing Built Around the Existing Position
Instead of selling the concentrated stock to buy a fund that likely owns some of the same company, we can make a custom model so the household’s total exposure looks like a properly diversified portfolio rather than an index fund plus an oversized bet stacked on top. This can open the door to systematic tax-loss harvesting that can be used to offset gains realized when the concentrated position is eventually trimmed.
2) Exchange Funds for Larger Positions
An exchange fund lets an investor contribute a concentrated stock to a pooled fund alongside other investors’ concentrated positions, in exchange for a diversified, pro-rata interest in the whole pool, without triggering a taxable sale. This is generally only available to accredited investors with sufficiently large positions (often $500,000 or more), and it comes with a required holding period, typically around seven years, plus reduced liquidity during that time. We consider this selectively, and only when the numbers and the client’s time horizon genuinely fit.
3) Borrow Against the Position as a Bridge, Not a Substitute
A securities-backed line of credit (SBLOC) provides spending liquidity by borrowing against a stock position, without triggering a taxable sale. It can let a household fund near-term needs while a longer, tax-managed diversification plan plays out in the background. We like SBLOCs when the repayment plan is clear and the risks are fully understood.
4) Charitable and Family Gifting as Diversification
Donating or gifting appreciated stock, rather than cash, avoids realizing the built-in capital gain while still accomplishing giving goals a household already had. For clients inclined toward philanthropy, shares donated directly or through a donor-advised fund reduce the position with no capital gains tax owed by the household. For clients focused on family wealth transfer, gifting shares to relatives in lower tax brackets can shift the eventual tax bill while reducing concentration.
If we still need to trim a position, spreading it across multiple tax years rather than all at once can help make the exit more efficient. We plan those sales against the household’s full tax picture – tax lot by tax lot, year by year – mindful of capital gains brackets, the NIIT threshold, state tax treatment, and knock-on effects like Medicare premium surcharges.
None of these tools is truly a secret or exotic. For households managing this on their own or working with an advisor who only manages model portfolios of funds, what tends to be missing is the coordination between the investment decision and the tax return, revisited as a standing part of the relationship rather than a one-time conversation.
As a fiduciary, our obligation isn’t to make the position disappear as fast as possible – it’s to help a household understand the real trade-offs and build a plan suited to their goals, their tax situation, and their tolerance for risk. If a concentrated position is part of your financial picture, we would welcome the conversation.
Doug “Buddy” Amis, CFP®